|
|||||||
|
|
|
|||||
|
|
|||||||
Back to ForumBack to English Composition I syllabus, fall 1999
Peer Review Sheet for Reflective Essay ( Essay #2) See Reflective Essay Assignment.
Author:
Reviewer:
1. Does the essay have a clear focus? What is its main point?
2. Does the writer move clearly from personal experience to reflections on the larger significance of that experience?
3. Does the writer present himself or herself in an appropriate way to the reader? Is the writer close to the reader or distant? Does the writer seem to invite the reader’s trust? Is the voice of the essay consistent and appropriate to the subject? Circle any phrases or sentences where the writer’s voice might be inappropriate to the subject or purpose.
4. Does the essay have vivid scenes and specific details? What were the best details? Where does the essay need more detail?
5. Does the essay use dialogue appropriately where necessary? Is the plot clear and effectively narrated?
6. What could be deleted from the essay?
7. What could be condensed?
8. What should be further developed or expanded?
9. What is the single most important improvement the writer needs to make in the next draft?
10. What did you like most about this essay?